What is dual-scenario mining valuation?

Dual-scenario valuation rates every miner under two explicit futures — Scenario B, in which the company executes its official roadmap, and Scenario A, a specific identified milestone miss — so the assumed-execution risk is visible rather than buried inside a single point estimate.

A single target hides which milestone risk is priced; naming Scenario A (the permit that slips, the financing that dilutes, the study that disappoints) makes the downside concrete and falsifiable.

The two scenarios are blended at the conviction weight (W) — how much of the optimistic case the read underwrites — so the output is a defended range, not an averaged-away guess.

It is the institutional shape of analysis: not "what will happen" but "here are both paths and what each is worth."

Worked example

  • VGZ — a permitted gold developer carrying a deposit toward a construction decision (NT Australia, Tier 1, 9-Factor 70.2) — the "orebody with a plan" where B-executes-vs-A-slips is sharpest. The per-ticker scenario table and milestone are members-only.

Ask your AI assistant

Prefer to ask an AI? GSA is now a connector your assistant can query directly — any covered miner's Re-Rate Score and factor breakdown, or a screen of the universe by metal, jurisdiction, and stage. Analytical classification, cited, with a link back.

See the methodology applied across ~300 miners — Sign up free

The methodology, monthly

One email per cycle with the State of the Platform and new explainers like this one. Structured methodology for junior precious-metals miners. Monthly. Sober.

Opens Substack to confirm. Free. Unsubscribe any time. Read past issues